Över videolänk träffar Kvalitetsmagasinet Andreas Bergh, docent i pedagogik som under många år fokuserat på kvalitet inom skolan och Anders Trumberg, doktor i kulturgeografi med fokus på skolsegregation.
Flytt av elever skapade möten men lyfte inte betygen
Skola
Den första gruppen elever som flyttades från Vivallaskolan i Örebro till fyra andra skolor förbättrade inte sina skolresultat – snarare tvärtom. Det visar en ny forskningsstudie.

I Örebro flyttades elever från Vivallaskolan till fyra andra skolor. Foto: Adobe Stock.
Någonting är fel
Du är inloggad som prenumerant hos förlaget Pauser Media, men nånting är fel. På din profilsida ser du vilka av våra produkter som du har tillgång till. Skulle uppgifterna inte stämma på din profilsida – vänligen kontakta vår kundtjänst.
Kvalitetsmagasinet premium
Läs vidare – starta din prenumeration
Redan prenumerant? Logga in och läs vidare.
Tillsammans med kollegorna Emma Arneback och Jan Jämte har de följt en grupp elever som flyttades till fyra nya skolor år 2017, efter ett beslut från kommunen. Vivallaskolan hade, som många skolor i utsatta områden, dragits med svag måluppfyllelse med en stor andel elever som inte nådde gymnasiebehörighet.
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


